The eighth floor

[Viv]

What do you think of Beccy so far? Does she fit in well? Did you prefer Laura?

So far, I like Becky: she's quick-witted; bright; naturally funny and relaxed and slots in well.

[Geezer7348]

I think there is very little difference between the two of them, both are bubbly and full of laughter. I think its still early days though for Becci as there is a lot of things Laura did which perhaps Becci may not!

[Viv]

I notice Beccy seems to have more confidence in answering Scott back, or giving cheek!

But yep, both are bubbly types. I don't know if Becky will go into libraries, etc. with megaphones.

Pls. can someone fix my title: I spelled her name wrong! oops.

[KingTutsWWH]

I'll comment, but I'm not going to vote as I feel it's somewhat unfair to compare the two, and I don't really have a preference.

I loved Laura on the show, but Beccy's quirky, frankly pretty bley cheeky sense of humour really does make me laugh. She seems to have a very good rapport with both Scott and Chappers too.

[Jono]

There's no need for a vote, Viv. I find that slightly unfair on them.

[Viv]

hmmm, I guess it is a bit now you mention it.

[Kelly]

I like her. She and Laura are very different, but they both fit into the show well, and that's all we can ask, really.

Her giggle needs to be a bit filthier though.

[Hugh.]

I like both of them, I think the change has changed the show, which sort of proves how much of a difference they make.

[Jono]

You know my first reaction, I hated the idea of bringing in a new face to the show so soon after Laura's departure. But I truly miss it when Beccy is away. I think she adds a lot to the show. It's also amusing to see a female with some geeky knowledge. Talking about RSS feeds and knowing what size fonts are. Haha.

[E*F*4L]

yeah beccy is ok

[simonf]

I agree with Jono saying that he misses her when she's not on the show. I was dreading Laura leaving but she has filled the spot nicely

[MissCorsham]

Speaking as someone who is very new to the whole Scott Mills show, I missed all the older stuff with Laura on there. But I think that Beccy balances things out nicely and catches jokes and things that the other two dont think of. Good to hear a female point of view from time to time too

[James R]

I miss Lauras antics with Scott. But as most have said Becky filled the slot nicely. Shame that we dont hearfrm Laura on weekends

[Hazrold]

I really like Becky, although I don't know what she looks like. I wouldn't say I prefer her to Laura though.

[ali2098]

I like Becky/Becki/Becci.

When Laura left I didn't think the show would be the same again, but she's really good. Fits into the show really well A good choice I think!

[Rob]

I noticed straight away. Even thought people say they sound the same they are different. They both do an ace job, Laura got involved a bit more I think. I know Becky is in the show alot but I think Laura would do more outrageous things (remember blow your load?). Becky probably will once she has fully warmed to the show but so far I think she is doing a great job.

[daniel_jp]

I think beccy was amuch needed addition to the show. Dont get me wrong laura was amazing and will always be part of the show but something needed changing and it turned out a new face was just it as it has added a whole new dimension over the last few months!

[Nik B.]

I Like Becky, she's not Laura, but shes just as good.

I do think she comes out with the funniest stuff sometimes too! shes Amazin'!

[Jono]

I Like Becky, she's not Laura

Really? God damn this BBC fakery!

[ali2098]

Really? God damn this BBC fakery!

We should ring up and complain. BBC Competitions code of conduct my ass

[Sam]

I wasn't listening to radio 1 when Laura was on Scott's show but I think Becky is doing well

[superchris0110]

Has this convo come up again? Its unfair to make any comparisons. Both are great