Jump to content
Unofficial Mills

Should Scott Move To Breakfast?


radio1fan

Recommended Posts

Nick Grimshaw will have been doing the breakfast show for 2 years in September and listeners will have gotten bored of his show by then ( he hasn't really had any good new features for a while) . While he might stay for a while longer, I don't think Ben Cooper would want someone doing it for 8 years like Moyles did! And he quite likes scott and in particular Innuendo Bingo! So why not have scott do it for at least till his contract expires. Nick would do Scott's show. I have quite liked The Scott Mills Show format and when scott covers the breakfast show it has worked really well! Tell me what you think about my idea!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nick Grimshaw will have been doing the breakfast show for 2 years in September and listeners will have gotten bored of his show by then ( he hasn't really had any good new features for a while) . While he might stay for a while longer, I don't think Ben Cooper would want someone doing it for 8 years like Moyles did! And he quite likes scott and in particular Innuendo Bingo! So why not have scott do it for at least till his contract expires. Nick would do Scott's show. I have quite liked The Scott Mills Show format and when scott covers the breakfast show it has worked really well! Tell me what you think about my idea!

I love the idea, but Scott has already said he would not want to do breakfast- he said its to much pressure. Grimmy Is doing really well at the moment, and Scott thinks that Grimmy is doing well too! The next move for Breakfast is Greg James.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Scott doesn't want breakfast and I think the show is perfect right now. Whenever he covers breakfast, he really does show what a great breakfast presenter he would have been though. Such a shame that the slot didn't become available 4/5 years ago.

Personally, I don't listen to the breakfast show because I can't stand Grimshaw by himself and I think the show severely lacks in good features and entertaining points of discussion. Personally, I think Annie Mac needs to co-host the show (even for 2/3 days a week). I actually think Grimmy is great when he's with Sara Cox or Annie - he sounds relaxed and can be quite funny and likeable when with them.) Also, their Sunday night show was brilliant.

I also think he needs a new production team as Fincham is weak and between him, Fiona & Ian Chaloner, there seems to be a lack of truly great ideas. For me, that's another reason why Greg should move to breakfast. His production team of Laura, Pippa & Travis are fantastic. Imagine Greg, Laura & Chris Smith as on-air voices with Pippa & Travis as Assistant Producers. That would be a brilliant breakfast show.

I can see R1 in 3 years looking like :

04:00 = Pete Allison

06:30 = Greg James

10:00 = Alice Levine

13:00 = Matt Edmondson/ Dev with Chris Stark ( Scott's irreplaceable though IMO and Matt and Dev just don't have the same rapport with him. Scott brings out the best in Chris.)

16:00 = Nick Grimshaw

19:00 = Zane Lowe

22:00 = Phil Taggart

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I like the idea of this negotiation between keeping Grimshaw on breakfast and allowing him a co-host. By no means is it to suggest he is weak but... I really don't want Ben Cooper rushing in Greg James right now. Grimshaw should be given a chance, and whilst I agree that some of his shows aren't up to standard I think Annie Mac could really save it. Why not?! I think the Radio 1 audience has become accustomed to solo hosts for breakfast and the zoo format which was employed by Chris Moyles. Must I remind you that in the eighties breakfast was co-hosted!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As long as the figures for grimmys show are near the 6 million mark he's safe on breakfast.He probably won't stay anywhere near as long as Moyles of course but he'll probably be there another couple of years at least .Sadly I think Scotts chances of hosting it are gone but he'll probably be back in april when Grimmy takes his next holiday

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As much as I would like to see Scott do it, it won't happen!

Ifmi was Ben cooper I would instantly move Fincham, he's not really suitable! Grimmy IS a great presenter just needs a strong production team to support him and his abilities! A co-host could instantly re-invent the show just like on 1xtra.. Could be anyone from stark to Mac, or dev or even a late night presenter, anyone to add some enthusiasm and ideas to the show!!

hello

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Finchham would be good on Greg's show, because he already has pippa and then he will have 2 members of the chris moyles production team!

That would be good, mainly because Greg needs to become the new Chris Moyles in a way, because he is following Chris' path of shows , early breakfast, drive time and when Grimmy goes or gets a co host, breakfast!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Scott won't get breakfast now. I think he'll remain in the afternoon slot, hopefully with a contract renewal to keep him there for another few years.

In terms of Grimmy, the show has definitely improved, but for the flagship Radio 1 show, it is still seriously lacking. Either a change in production is needed, or a swap of Grimmy and Greg. I think the latter could happen sometime this year, depending on how RAJAR's go.

I used to like Fincham on Moyles' show, but I think it was a bit of a mistake to move him to breakfast producer so quickly! To go from AP on breakfast to producer of the 22:00 slot to producer of breakfast in the space of a few months was too much of a change too quickly, especially considering he was going to be the producer of a brand new breakfast show. I like Matt, but I think Radio 1 have made a mistake of promoting him too quickly, and perhaps he would have been better to going to be the producer of a different daytime show first.

I still think that Greg's team would be more suitable on breakfast. They seem to be more of a 'team'. Perhaps they're waiting for Greg to be completely 'ready' for breakfast before they move him.

Like you say, there does seem to be a similar pattern of Moyles' Radio 1 career and Greg's. Is Nick going to be on breakfast for around 3 years then like Sara before a swap? We'll see. I do agree though that a better production team with clearer roles, and a second presenter (Annie would be perfect - their evening show used to be really good!) would improve things a lot. At least Radio 1 have finally realised that listening to a team having banter between themselves on breakfast is more what people want to hear, although more of a team feel needs to be implemented.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've never quite understood why the Breakfast show has so many people working on it. It has Nick (obviously), Matt, Fiona, Ian and Amy (the TA) plus a newsreader. It was exactly the same when Moyles hosted it. Moyles, Dave, Rachael, Aled, Matt and 2 newsreaders.

I also don't understand Ian's role on the show. Most days he strolls in at 0830 except when Matt or Fiona are absent meaning he is there from 0630. Does he work behind the scenes on other daytime shows?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If Greg was to take over breakfast, this is what I'd do with the schedule. Firstly he would cover Grimmy during summer and then take over in September.

Then I would remove Gemma from early breakfast (after she starts). , put her on Sunday morning 10-1PM with Matt doing Saturday. Get a new male to do weekend breakfast, put Dev back on earlies! Greg's show would be done by Nick!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Scott's effectively out of the running for Breakfast now, which is a shame. Great cover presenter though, long may that last. Afternoons are the best place for him, as that slot likely has an older audience who aren't at school etc; Hopefully his contract will be renewed for a couple more years for that slot, then here's what I want to happen.

Breakfast (September 2014) - Greg James - He's been primed for this slot with his progression, Earlies > Afternoons > Drive, Breakfast is the next slot for him. Chris Smith and Laura would complete the 'on air' team, in a proper zoo format.

Mid Mornings - Alice Levine - I love her cover, and I think she has a very bright future at Radio 1. Fearne Cotton can move to a weekend slot or leave, I don't mind either way. There needs to be a drastic shift in production on this slot too... 'Send me 3 words about the track of the day' does not a good feature make.

Afternoons - Matt Edmonson - Stylistically the only presenter who could take over from Scott, and with the right set of features I think he could be great. Chris Stark would do well to stick around as a contributor in this slot.

Drivetime - Nick Grimshaw - Cox/Moyles style swap, I think Nick would be much better suited to Drivetime than he is breakfast.

Any thoughts?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Scott's effectively out of the running for Breakfast now, which is a shame. Great cover presenter though, long may that last. Afternoons are the best place for him, as that slot likely has an older audience who aren't at school etc; Hopefully his contract will be renewed for a couple more years for that slot, then here's what I want to happen.

Breakfast (September 2014) - Greg James - He's been primed for this slot with his progression, Earlies > Afternoons > Drive, Breakfast is the next slot for him. Chris Smith and Laura would complete the 'on air' team, in a proper zoo format.

Mid Mornings - Alice Levine - I love her cover, and I think she has a very bright future at Radio 1. Fearne Cotton can move to a weekend slot or leave, I don't mind either way. There needs to be a drastic shift in production on this slot too... 'Send me 3 words about the track of the day' does not a good feature make.

Afternoons - Matt Edmonson - Stylistically the only presenter who could take over from Scott, and with the right set of features I think he could be great. Chris Stark would do well to stick around as a contributor in this slot.

Drivetime - Nick Grimshaw - Cox/Moyles style swap, I think Nick would be much better suited to Drivetime than he is breakfast.

Any thoughts?

Completely agree with your suggestions.

Definitely Alice Levine on mid-mornings. She has really surprised me just how good she is. An excellent presenter who knows her music, and she also comes across as very likeable. She couldn't be more suitable for that slot.

Matt Edmondson I can see maybe doing drivetime, and Dev having the afternoon slot, as I think if Grimmy loses breakfast, I don't think he will stick around at Radio 1.

But definitely Greg doing breakfast! He is much more suitable, so is the rest of his team. On the subject of Laura, is she returning to Radio 1 after having her baby? As Pippa has now taken over as producer.

If Greg was to move to breakfast, an additional producer and his current team would be needed, which would work out perfect for Laura's return. The Greg James Show with Pippa and Laura as day/show producer (or whichever way round), AP as Travis and Chris Smith as newsreader with a zoo style format would be perfect for breakfast.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Completely agree with your suggestions.

Definitely Alice Levine on mid-mornings. She has really surprised me just how good she is. An excellent presenter who knows her music, and she also comes across as very likeable. She couldn't be more suitable for that slot.

Matt Edmondson I can see maybe doing drivetime, and Dev having the afternoon slot, as I think if Grimmy loses breakfast, I don't think he will stick around at Radio 1.

But definitely Greg doing breakfast! He is much more suitable, so is the rest of his team. On the subject of Laura, is she returning to Radio 1 after having her baby? As Pippa has now taken over as producer.

If Greg was to move to breakfast, an additional producer and his current team would be needed, which would work out perfect for Laura's return. The Greg James Show with Pippa and Laura as day/show producer (or whichever way round), AP as Travis and Chris Smith as newsreader with a zoo style format would be perfect for breakfast.

This would be great. I think Grimmy will stay with Radio 1. He is more in touch with Radio 1 teams than you think- he's also really friendly with Ben Cooper. Grimmy would go to Drivetime if Greg took breakfast.

Also Laura has now left Radio 1. She will not be on Gregs show anytime soon, Pippa is the producer for the show

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This would be great. I think Grimmy will stay with Radio 1. He is more in touch with Radio 1 teams than you think- he's also really friendly with Ben Cooper. Grimmy would go to Drivetime if Greg took breakfast.

Also Laura has now left Radio 1. She will not be on Gregs show anytime soon, Pippa is the producer for the show

I had a feeling Laura might have left for good. A shame as I always liked her on air, but Pippa is definitely a good replacement.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Think Grimmy needs another chance as mentioned, definitely a new production team needed! If not would love him on drive, he was really great at it ages ago covering scott and then greg! Matt would be a great ultimate replacement for Scott. Love Alice Levine, don't see why her and Phil Taggart couldn't go together to Fearne's slot, (with a good production team that don't play loads of music and do nothing).

hello

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Think Grimmy needs another chance as mentioned, definitely a new production team needed! If not would love him on drive, he was really great at it ages ago covering scott and then greg! Matt would be a great ultimate replacement for Scott. Love Alice Levine, don't see why her and Phil Taggart couldn't go together to Fearne's slot, (with a good production team that don't play loads of music and do nothing).

I think Grimmy has a brilliant production team. They are very good and engaging on air. I think the features do need a revamp though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Posts

    • Find Noah Kahan is just busker music. I mean I was pleasantly surprised that Ezra collective were in session for Jack Saunders on his new shoes and he is playing their latest track wouldn’t have thought few years back that at 6pm in the evening jazz music would be played. I hope if can get the green light and launch the 00s/10s station that the focus is on more new music be it pop mainstream and alternative genres on the main 1
    • Scott's show is perfect for the office. If Matt and Mol have a podcast I'd listen to that. All the fun without the Gen Z rappers. 
    • Similar to SZA’s Kill Bill, the word “kill” had been initially cut out of Taylor Swift’s Fortnight. But it seems like they are now playing an unedited version.
    • Also hopefully won't get my head bitten off for this but I'd say of the current Radio 1 DJs the one arguably most similar to Scott Mills's latter time on Radio 1 would be Mollie. I'm not saying she's as good as Scott was to be clear but she is that sort of vibe. 'Future Pop' is exactly the sort of music Scott would be championing and you can tell Mollie has the same passion for it that Scott did. There's that Party Anthems link too - a show Matt & Mol do that previously Scott did and they bring a similar energy to how Scott did that makes it a fun listen. Matt & Mollie seem to just have that natural connection with the listeners that Scott & Chris did that you can't manufacture.
    • I find at the minute I'm a bit of a nomad when it comes to radio stations. Often the Radio 1 playlist really doesn't appeal to me these days and I did wonder is it just me tiring of new music but then I'll listen to Future Pop and Party Anthems and there's loads of tunes on there that I love and they're excellent listens but just too few of those make it to the playlist. Radio 2 may arguably be more to my taste music wise but also often feels too rooted on the past. Plus much of the content just doesn't appeal to me and verges on the 'mumsy' side. Plus Radio 2's new music can feel very 'middle of the road' - just because I don't enjoy some of the Radio 1 new stuff it doesn't mean I want Take That & Will Young as 'new music'. For me currently if I'm tuning in for radio it'll be Jordan North on Capital Breakfast, on Radio 1 Matt & Mollie, (if Jamie is off)  Going Home and Sam & Danni plus there's also Capital Dance and Mistajam. They all hit the mark for me in a way other shows don't.
    • Matt & Mol for me. For those that enjoyed Scott's Radio 1 show, Matt & Mollie are the natural successors (even more so than Scott's Radio 2 show) - two best mates doing a fun show packed full of content For one thing Matt & Mol inherited two of Scott's ex producers in Amy & Helena. Some Matt & Mollie features you could easily imagine Scott doing e.g. Matt vs Mollie and some feel near identical (can see 'Battletracks' taking the old 'Bangers' slot as it feels heavily based on that feature). Also while this may be down to being a weekend show Matt & Mol's show does seem to lean in a more pop direction and seems to deviate from the playlist more than some other shows- which helps as the Radio 1 playlist can be quite marmite and get samey very quickly. Something just doesn't hit the mark for me with Scott on Radio 2. It feels like it's aimed at somebody about a decade older than me and relies heavily on Noughties nostalgia. Scott too I feel works best with somebody else to work off and is missing that fun element he had with Chris and previously Chappers. It's fine but not something I'll go out my way to listen to.  
    • Random idea time: condense all the throwback shows into one three hour show from 10am to 1pm on a Saturday, get Katie Thistleton back to host it (as Charlie does with Dance Anthems on a Saturday), call it “Radio 1’s Bottomless Brunch with Katie Thistleton” and just have 3 hours of throwbacks from across the decades, not just 00s or 10s, just a mix of everything. The occasional 90s anthem, tunes from the early 2020s, just 3 hours of pure feel good
    • I think it's great the amount of choice out there right now. I could happily listen to Greg or Jordan in the morning, Going Home or Huw Stephens in the evening, or Scott and Matt and Mollie in afternoons.  Still a few times when I'm channel hopping but maybe that's healthy to check out what's around.  As that research pointed out, Scott is good for minimal distractions. If you want some chaos I dare say it'll be Matt and Mollie offering that.  Plenty of my friends say it's the Radio 1 playlist that puts them off, even if they like the DJs. So Radio 2 is more preferable. 
    • I quite quickly gave up on Scott’s show on R2 as I realised it wasn’t my kind of vibe. I do listen to the Scott Mills weekly to catch up, because I still think Scott is great, but there is just something missing (for example, he played out some clips recently of the old sleep recording app from the R1 days, and didn’t play ‘go and open the window Garry’ - or if he did, it didn’t make it to the podcast.) I don’t see them changing it now or making it any ‘younger’ than it is.   Matt & Mollie in the afternoon is something that I’m really looking forward to. They are such an interesting and funny listen. It has given me a different dilemma though, as 1pm has been the perfect time for me to catch up on the Capital breakfast show and takes me perfectly to the end of my working day, so now I’ll probably have to forego listening to that and stick with R1 for Matt & Mollie. These shows need podcasts because it’s already giving me fomo. 
    • Even for the older Radio 1 listeners (of which there are still quite a few) Scott’s show doesn’t feel quite right.  (That’s nothing on Scott who sounds good but more the station sound and content). Since moving to Capital Breakfast I haven’t been listening to much Radio 1.  I always found the shows outside of Breakfast and Drive more wallpaper due to my working day and the show content of RMC and Dean and Vicky so Capital is just background noise to me after enjoying Breakfast.
    • I love Scott but if you're a 20 or 30 something that enjoyed his last few years of Radio 1 the Radio 2 show just doesn't translate. Stars from Neighbours or 90s singers just aren't my cup of tea and I can't get enthused about some has been at Radio 2 in the Park or some country music countdown.  Until that changes I will probably more likely listen to Matt and Mollie.  The Steve Wright fans think Radio 2 has turned into Radio 1 but it has a long way to go to win over the older R1 audience. 
    • Radio 2 brought in Scott to bring the afternoon audience age down, but I feel with Matt and Mollie replacing Dean and Vicky they're going to be competing for a similar audience. Will Scott's show evolve to bring in more listeners or do you think they will be comfortable with the audience they currently have?
    • Yes I'm the same with 6Music. Huw Stephens offers something different. 
    • They are an answer. I do listen to 6 Music quite a bit but kind of feel like it isn’t for me unlike the New Music Fix Daily, Huw Stephens who I’d happily listen to. Think it’s a generational thing and music preference. But it’s like how 1 Xtra cut down Snoochie Shy’s nightly show to just Monday and with Wednesday and Thursday with just playlist programme. I just miss the days of having more choice of that time of night.
    • Practically speaking, Riley & Coe on 6Music is the answer to that problem - but I get your overall point.
×
×
  • Create New...