Jump to content
Unofficial Mills

The Review Show with Nihal

DJ89

By DJ89
in BBC Radio 1

 Share

Recommended Posts

Jono

Jono

Posted
Posted

I think you perhaps have to be a Nihal fan to enjoy it. As a big fan of his weekend show, I like it. I like the idea and I agree it's a better use of an hour than trying to get an INMWT show in that time. There is nothing decent on TV tonight and I can see this being a decent alternative.

It looks like Brooker has tweeted about the show so there's quite a big following on Twitter talking about the show. Some people who have never heard Radio 1 refuse to tune in, those that will give it a go seem to enjoy it.

I would question the rating system a bit. Rating something "70%" is a bit random. I'll say more when it's over.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Robbie Keane

Robbie Keane

Posted
Posted

I love Brooker, which is why I don't understand how he can hate Chris Moyles so much and yet seem to have a fond affection for Nihal, who refers to him as UBER-reviewer. Nihal is practically everything that Brooker rants about on Screenwipe.

I reiterate my love for Brooker, but he seems to be starting to, dare I say, sell out a little.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Jono

Jono

Posted
Posted
I love Brooker, which is why I don't understand how he can hate Chris Moyles so much and yet seem to have a fond affection for Nihal, who refers to him as UBER-reviewer. Nihal is practically everything that Brooker rants about on Screenwipe.

Do you not think someone else might have just wrote that description?

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Joe Boy

Joe Boy

Posted
Posted

Trouble with Nihal is he always seems to try too hard. Speech Debelle was just trying to make a serious point and he kept interrupting her with lame jokes. No need! I like the concept of the show, but why not try and be serious, just for an hour? I'm not asking for a Radio 4 style show, but young people won't tune out just because they hear something mildly intelligent.

I also think the rating system is unecessary. If the reviewers make their point well enough, there shouldn't be any need for them to come up with a random percentage.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Jono

Jono

Posted
Posted
Trouble with Nihal is he always seems to try too hard. Speech Debelle was just trying to make a serious point and he kept interrupting her with lame jokes. No need!

I found it funny. I guess it's that marmite opinion of Nihal there. I actually have found Speech Debelle quite arrogant.

I also think the rating system is unecessary. If the reviewers make their point well enough, there shouldn't be any need for them to come up with a random percentage.

You might be right here. There's something about the ratings that doesn't work and you might be right about scrapping it. The idea is the best one is played tomorrow on Greg's show.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Joe Boy

Joe Boy

Posted
Posted
I found it funny. I guess it's that marmite opinion of Nihal there. I actually have found Speech Debelle quite arrogant.

You might be right here. There's something about the ratings that doesn't work and you might be right about scrapping it. The idea is the best one is played tomorrow on Greg's show.

Ah I see, not a bad idea. Maybe a mark out of 10 would be better then. I don't get how you can distinguish between say 71 and 72%. Nihal's OK, I just think he needs to calm down a bit. He's actually a really good broadcaster, but he should just be himself rather than feeling the need to be funny or clever all the time.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Jono

Jono

Posted
Posted
It's essentially Hit, Miss, or Maybe from Live & Kicking, but with a more annoying host.

I like that element of it though. Retro.

If I had my wicked ways I would probably do something with the ratings. I would probably brand it more as 'BBC Radio 1's Music Review Show' (because for some reason I thought it'd be a mix of all sorts). I would also probably get more listener interaction involved if it's going to be live. Maybe some pre-recorded callers, take some texts or perhaps a fan page of some sort where people can give their opinions before the show and take the better opinions. It's just that having three minor celebrities is great. They just don't necessarily represent our views.

I do not doubt that opinions will be taken on board and that it's a work-in-progress show and format.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Joe Boy

Joe Boy

Posted
Posted

Another thing about the ratings is that Nihal keeps interrupting their opinions to get their percentage.

Overall I think they probably have too many songs in the hour, perhaps they should stick to the big 5 releases of the week. Also, a bit of film, TV or book discussion wouldn't go amiss, just to add a bit of variety.

And Nihal needs to calm down.

But overall I'd give the show 63%...

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Jono

Jono

Posted
Posted

Is it just me or did Speech Debelle appear to take it a bit personally she didn't win the ratings thing?

Another thing about the ratings is that Nihal keeps interrupting their opinions to get their percentage.

I sense it's due to the time limitations. Part of me wouldn't mind an extra say ten minutes on a podcast.

I like the idea of this show. I'll be listening in the future.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
daniel_jp

daniel_jp

Posted
Posted

Liking the concept alot. What I heard was good and I think this kind of show falls better with Nihal. I hope this idea works out and the shows comes into its own over the next few weeks. I personally would like to see this kind of show on every day 9-10pm with Nihal as anchor.

Mon - The documentary thing is good - maybe a kind of Panorama for our generation on the radio.

Tues - keep with the music theme

Wed could be a book/arts review programme

Thurs - Movies.

Liking this radio1 - one of the best shows so far to come from this re-shuffle and think its the kind of thing that keep radio 1 edgey above the rest!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Posts

    • TMD_24
      Radio 1 Schedule Changes

      By TMD_24 · Posted

      Radio 1 at Parklife will be presented by Vicky and Nat. Nat is currently listed to present her usual Sunday show on that weekend but I imagine that will change and someone else will be doing it instead. The Radio 1 presenters at Download will be Daniel P Carter, Jack Saunders, Alyx Holcombe and Nels Hylton.
    • TMD_24
      Radio 1 Schedule Changes

      By TMD_24 · Posted

      Nat in for Dean with Vicky as well that day.
    • Jono
      Matt and Mollie to replace Dean and Vicky

      By Jono · Posted

      So the end of weekend afternoons this week - new show is July 1st.
    • Lily Georgia
      Radio 1 Schedule Changes

      By Lily Georgia · Posted

      Arielle is in for Greg on Monday 27th May.
    • R1Fan1
      Going Home with Vick, Katie and Jamie

      By R1Fan1 · Posted

      He’s definitely gotten better and the show has sounded fine this week. I think it been at its best when it’s been Katie and Jamie or Vick and Katie. Vick and Jamie are ok together, but I do think the show sounds better when it’s Vick and Katie and therefore I still don’t really understand the point of the trio.    Jamie is, however, a lot better than Danny Beard! 
    • BBCAaron
      Next Radio 1 boss

      By BBCAaron · Posted

      The RAJAR coming on later this year reflecting later summer to autumn will be interesting to how it reflects Matt and Mollie in afternoons to the revised changes on radio 1’s new music slots and the schedule re-shuffling Radio 3 introducing a new slate of programmes. Then, later on this year have speech radio stations having domestic political coverage of the election but also America’s presidential election.  
    • xxladybarefootxx
      Going Home with Vick, Katie and Jamie

      By xxladybarefootxx · Posted

      I actually caught snippets of today’s show, and I found it much better than the last time I listened. I have made it no secret that I like Jamie on the radio, I was surprised by how much I enjoyed Matt & him together last year. People have criticised him for not being relatable, but I have to agree with the comment above that I have always found him a naturally warm person to listen to. Maybe the going home set up was something that needed settling in and things are starting to take shape.  It must have been difficult for him joining an established duo in Vick & Katie to begin with.  Jamie was great on something songs today, fully engaged in the caller and sounded like a real presenter. Maybe he is doing as a lot of us hoped and really learning as he goes, how to do it properly. 
    • Bluestraw
      Going Home with Vick, Katie and Jamie

      By Bluestraw · Posted

      Agree with this. The anti-Jamie feeling was IMO quite influenced by the negativity around him replacing Jordan, since Jordan was exceptional and also universally loved. When people mention Danny and Jamie in the same sentence about bad hiring decisions I almost choke - Jamie may not be perfect but he's several leagues better than Danny already and has bags of potential. Danny is poor and has shown zero potential...
    • R1 Insider
      Next Radio 1 boss

      By R1 Insider · Posted

      Jamie started 4 March, and the figures only going up to 31 March, so it isn't reliable. But it has shown the numbers have dropped in afternoons compared to last quarter. It looks like it's Capital's gain.
    • onlyME
      Next Radio 1 boss

      By onlyME · Posted

      Do these audience figures reflect Jordan leaving and Jamie replacing him?
    • jj996
      Going Home with Vick, Katie and Jamie

      By jj996 · Posted

      I think Jamie is really starting to settle into the role well. He comes across as really warm, and genuinely invested in the listeners when he’s talking to them which is nice. I think he’s building a really great relationship with Vicki and Katie too. His recent great company podcast is great too, where he has quite a deep chat with someone new each week. He’s clearly a very genuine person and I think he has some real potential.
    • BBCAaron
      Radio 1 Schedule Changes

      By BBCAaron · Posted

      Most probably. But do wonder what the future of the relax themed programmes will be when they officially wind down that service.
    • GregJames_fan
      Radio 1 Schedule Changes

      By GregJames_fan · Posted

      I think it's just to replace Wind Down presents... which was in that timeslot, and I'm guessing Chillout Anthems was just a buffer since it'll still be played at 06:00 on Sundays.
    • BBCAaron
      Next Radio 1 boss

      By BBCAaron · Posted

      With listening on the U.K. for the industry in general it is good overall as most stations reach is on the up and shows radio to be more sustainable and stable outlet than linear televisions channels. This RAJAR I think with the increase shift to DAB+ the BBC will be able to say it has it’s audiences for the proposed new stations it wishes to launch and think the new innovative ideas that it seems Jack himself can take credit for on the new music show think the younger under 30 gen z demographic could increase se in that time-slot. 
    • Lily Georgia
      Radio 1 Schedule Changes

      By Lily Georgia · Posted

      Conor Knight is in for Sam & Danni on Saturday 8th & Sunday 9th June. It's Radio 1 at Parklife, 13.00-16.00 on Saturday 8th & Sunday 9th June. Matt & Mollie are in for Greg from Monday 10th to Friday 14th June - it's just Matt on the Thursday. It's Radio 1 at Download, 13.00-16.00 on Friday 14th June.
×
×
  • Create New...