Jump to content
Unofficial Mills

Dean and Vicky - what happened?

GeekTalk51

By GeekTalk51
in BBC Radio 1

 Share

Recommended Posts

GeekTalk51

GeekTalk51

Posted
Posted

It was always going to be a rough ride taking over from one of the most long running and successful daytime shows in Radio 1 history, but the fact they’re being taken off air after less than two years feels significant to me.  Vicky going to weekends is obviously a demotion from weekday daytimes, and while there is definitely a way back for Dean from early breakfast it’s absolutely a backward career move.  Did they always plan this to be short term?  I can’t imagine they did.  Others on here have said the figures held up decently and from what I’ve seen they did, maybe qualitative research such as focus groups was really poor for them?  Why do folks think Aled pulled the plug this early?

BBCAaron

BBCAaron

Posted
Posted
2 hours ago, GeekTalk51 said:

It was always going to be a rough ride taking over from one of the most long running and successful daytime shows in Radio 1 history, but the fact they’re being taken off air after less than two years feels significant to me.  Vicky going to weekends is obviously a demotion from weekday daytimes, and while there is definitely a way back for Dean from early breakfast it’s absolutely a backward career move.  Did they always plan this to be short term?  I can’t imagine they did.  Others on here have said the figures held up decently and from what I’ve seen they did, maybe qualitative research such as focus groups was really poor for them?  Why do folks think Aled pulled the plug this early?

They spent tow years in the slot had Aled wanted to and management and commission would they would’ve retained this daytime programme so can’t imagine this was always the plan but rather pulling out and drafting a different plan. To an extent I think it’s tough to see the direction and vision of why and what is being done. 

I feel at this point the station needs new management and feels like management should be a five year term for a station like Radio 1.

AndyK77

AndyK77

Posted
Posted

Two years isn’t exactly a failure - it’s only seen as a failure by comparison to how long many national radio shows last.  I suspect a tonne of factors at work in the show ending now.

Nick Grimshaw only did two years on drive after breakfast and back in the day Mark and Lard lasted 6 months or so on Breakfast.

Rob86

Rob86

Posted
Posted

It is definitely a failure and they’re both going to lesser slots, whatever the spin. Grimmy leaving Drive was his decision after a long successful stint at Radio 1.

It seemed pretty random to me when the appointment was made. They’d never done a show together. Vicky had no regular slot on Radio 1. And when you pair people up, it so often doesn’t work - it really needs to be trialled first.

The people involved have got to be great broadcasters and genuine friends. Vicky just seems to giggle at everything.  I’ve always found it really hard to listen to and that’s so rare for me to say about a Radio 1 show. But it has me turning off. Roll on July. 

AndyK77

AndyK77

Posted
Posted
9 minutes ago, Rob86 said:

It is definitely a failure and they’re both going to lesser slots, whatever the spin. Grimmy leaving Drive was his decision after a long successful stint at Radio 1.

It seemed pretty random to me when the appointment was made. They’d never done a show together. Vicky had no regular slot on Radio 1. And when you pair people up, it so often doesn’t work - it really needs to be trialled first.

The people involved have got to be great broadcasters and genuine friends. Vicky just seems to giggle at everything.  I’ve always found it really hard to listen to and that’s so rare for me to say about a Radio 1 show. But it has me turning off. Roll on July. 

Don't get me wrong - the show being axed says that the station accepted it was no longer the right thing to continue with but "disaster" is too strong.  They didn't kill the ratings.  (And I am saying this as somebody who never really liked the show).

Ash101

Ash101

Posted
Posted

I truly believe this show only came about because of the pressures on BBC management to have a daytime show from outside of London.

They’ve done it for a bit, increased the weekend quota and are still retaining another slot on weekdays. But the pressure is no longer there & now they can make a programming decision based on Matt & Mollie bringing a better show along.

That podcast from the start of the year told us everything we needed to know about Vicky only being asked 2 days before the show was announced.

Agree it’s not a disaster as such, but this is the only time in recent memory that management have ended a show without talent calling time. 

ianwilk1999

ianwilk1999

Posted
Posted

For me, there wasn't that entertaining factor about it that there was when scott and chris did the show. It's not difficult to say is this entertaining or not for the audience and lots of what they kept doing regularly simply wasn't up to scratch.

Whenever I listened to Mills it made the day go faster when on call and it was quiet, or doing paperwork. All dean and vickys show made me do was eye roll.

Perhaps management also did the same thing in the end?

onlyME

onlyME

Posted
Posted

I think it was an experiment, they may have been made aware it was a short-term thing. Who knows, maybe Matt or Mollie threatened to walk and were given promotion? Maybe Dean or Vicky wanted to do something different? Don't think it all has to be seen with such negativity. 

IamNotFromUK

IamNotFromUK

Posted
Posted
22 hours ago, BBCAaron said:

I feel at this point the station needs new management and feels like management should be a five year term for a station like Radio 1.

I'm not sure about this. Radio is all about continuity and management changes every few years might break this, because every new boss would want to change something. 

AndyK77

AndyK77

Posted
Posted

But 2 years really isn't that short...so many daytime shows over time have lasted that or less.

If it was a true disaster it would have lasted 6 months.

(And I am saying this as a non-fan).  

It's not a success story clearly but not a disaster either.

Dan18F1

Dan18F1

Posted
Posted
41 minutes ago, IamNotFromUK said:

I'm not sure about this. Radio is all about continuity and management changes every few years might break this, because every new boss would want to change something. 

I agree, as much as I think Aled has made a couple of recent questionable decisions, after the next few months the last thing radio 1 will need is more upheaval. I think (unless anyone chooses to leave) there probably shouldn’t be any changes for at least a couple of years. Radio 1 needs a period of stability now. 

Sara97

Sara97

Posted
Posted

They are not popular with listeners - look on social media, they lost half the listeners according to many on this forum and other forums. They don’t gel and argue a lot behind the scene which they’ve openly admitted.
Dean is self centred and narcissistic, he doesn’t play well with others. When he did a show with Mollie about Eurovision, he tried to dominate it. Whenever they have challenges and everyone is on, he always talks over everyone. Greg isn’t a fan of him. 

I cannot wait for Dean to go back to Gaydio and stay there. If he gets breakfast; that would be the end of radio 1. They both have been demoted - I feel for Vicky. 

wbroom12

wbroom12

Posted
Posted
On 3/5/2024 at 10:05 AM, GeekTalk51 said:

It was always going to be a rough ride taking over from one of the most long running and successful daytime shows in Radio 1 history, but the fact they’re being taken off air after less than two years feels significant to me.  Vicky going to weekends is obviously a demotion from weekday daytimes, and while there is definitely a way back for Dean from early breakfast it’s absolutely a backward career move.  Did they always plan this to be short term?  I can’t imagine they did.  Others on here have said the figures held up decently and from what I’ve seen they did, maybe qualitative research such as focus groups was really poor for them?  Why do folks think Aled pulled the plug this early?

I don't think Dean and Vicky was the long term plan for the show. Replacing Mills and Stark was always an impossible job for whoever took it on and would have had flak for it. I think they wanted someone in that was  far away from that show ready for now. I don't know if Matt and Mollie were always the intended recipients of it or if they had someone else planned. 

At the time there was a lack of quality available besides Matt and Mollie and maybe they wanted to give Dean and Vicky airtime as they have big plans for them moving forward

ianwilk1999

ianwilk1999

Posted
Posted

It feels so weird that everyone is saying they are being demoted and Dean is going to 5am and they are just carrying on the show as normal. It hasn't worked that's a given, I think the sooner its off afternoons the better.

What does everyone think the next move for Dean will be after earlies. Am I right in thinking Arielle has done them for years and is that what would be called overnights? Overs for us is up till 8am!

It's a shame there seems to be an obsession with shows coming from different places

Ash101

Ash101

Posted
Posted
On 3/8/2024 at 6:28 PM, ianwilk1999 said:

It feels so weird that everyone is saying they are being demoted and Dean is going to 5am and they are just carrying on the show as normal. It hasn't worked that's a given, I think the sooner its off afternoons the better.

What does everyone think the next move for Dean will be after earlies. Am I right in thinking Arielle has done them for years and is that what would be called overnights? Overs for us is up till 8am!

It's a shame there seems to be an obsession with shows coming from different places

I do wonder what the 4 month hold up is? Are they doing it out of respect for Dean, Vicky or Arielle to remain in their current slot? Are Matt & Mollie not available till then? 

  • 4 weeks later...
DC

DC

Posted
Posted

This feels like Colin and Edith after Mark & Lard all over again. From what I recall by the end of 2006 it was Edith on her own for a good while. They'd already moved Colin Murray to nights where I must be honest he did a cracking show circa late 00s.

But it was never going to replace what was before on afternoons. Deja vu imo, with Scott and Chris. It does feel like they may have been the stop gap as sad as it sounds, until time moves further on and totally new different talent goes onto afternoons. Following on from Scott Mills was always going to be an impossible job. I'm not just saying it for the sake of it either. He nailed early breakfast, my favourite times was drive with Chappers, he wasn't half bad with Chris Stark either. Whoever came on it was always going to be dammed if you do, damned if you don't for a couple of years in a way. It will all settle and Scott's days at Radio 1 before you blink will be 10/20 years ago.

on the grid.

DC

DC

Posted
Posted
On 4/11/2024 at 8:05 AM, Jono said:

Loved Colin's evening show, was over too soon, in my opinion.

I thought it fit perfectly, I don't understand why it didn't go on longer than it did. 

on the grid.

AndyK77

AndyK77

Posted
Posted
10 hours ago, DC said:

I thought it fit perfectly, I don't understand why it didn't go on longer than it did. 

Was that not purely down to him wanting to get more into the journalism side of broadcasting?

coffeeandgin

coffeeandgin

Posted
Posted

It does feel like since it was announced that Dean & Vicky will no longer be a pairing with the schedule changes like it's very often Dean or Vicky that's on with the other away as if both have sort of given up on the pairing.

Combine that with that Going Home continuing to be a show where you can quite guess what combination will be in and it feels rare that the schedule is actually what it should be.

  • 3 weeks later...
lochnessa

lochnessa

Posted
Posted

Dare I say they've sounded great this past week?  Very much gelling.  Maybe less pressure?  Seem to be having a genuinely good time and not forcing things.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Posts

    • NathanS
      Radio 2 Schedule Changes

      By NathanS · Posted

      Phil Williams in for OJ Borg tonight and Thursday.
    • Noah
      Radio 1 Schedule Changes

      By Noah · Posted

      Saturday 13th December - Headie One sits in for Kenny Allstar on Radio1's Rap Show
    • NathanS
      Radio 2 Schedule Changes

      By NathanS · Posted

      As it stands, he's on until Christmas Eve. First time in a few years. It's in Wycombe, where Vernon performed last year (or the year before). Vernon also did his show and panto for a week. A long day but it's doable now he's on in the morning Mark Goodier is doing the breakfast show from Boxing Day up to Friday 2nd January, then Sara's on for the week starting 5th January, so Scott will be off for some of his panto run.
    • Darren m
      Radio 2 Schedule Changes

      By Darren m · Posted

      Is Scott still on breakfast wonder how he is doing both 
    • GeekTalk51
      Radio 1 Schedule Changes

      By GeekTalk51 · Posted

      Mollie no longer on with Nat and Vicky Thursday afternoon, so it’s just those two covering Weds and Thus.
    • NathanS
      Radio 2 Schedule Changes

      By NathanS · Posted

      Saturday 3rd January as well. Rylan's on today, although it's pre recorded so his last live show of the year was last week.
    • GrimsbyGal
      5 December 2025: Shirley Ballas saves a life and Lloyd Griffith gets a 10

      By GrimsbyGal · Posted

      Did someone drop out? There's usually three guests. 
    • ReviewBot
      5 December 2025: Shirley Ballas saves a life and Lloyd Griffith gets a 10

      By ReviewBot · Posted

      “It rattled my pot.” “She nailed her line.” “His eyes are saying, get this off me now.” Scott opens with the familiar December traditions — underwhelming Christmas trees, loose reindeer, and even a Lancashire earthquake that “rattled my pot” when he woke up, leaving him feeling “a little bit sick… like being on a Big Dipper.” He immediately turns to a question for listeners: “Do you put your dog in a Christmas jumper?” And thus begins a morning-long saga about festive pets. Tina brings nativity pride and festive mum energy Tina beams as she recounts Athena’s very first nativity. “She nailed her line. She looked incredible, and she sang her little heart out… it was the proudest moment of my life.” Of course, Scott presses on whether she cried: “Yes, of course I cried… I took about 2 million photos.” She then reenacts Athena’s impressive line, which she now knows by heart: “Our tale begins in a land far away where sandals were cool and donkeys were the main form of transport.” Tina also reveals she bribed Athena with: “A chocolate ice cream with Oreos on top… and a chocolate milk.” Her motherly glow continues through the hour — the perfect counterbalance to Scott’s dog-jumper mania. Scott’s dog jumper confession becomes a whole mood Scott has bought Teddy an Argyle Christmas jumper… and then a matching jumper for himself. The photo he shows Tina gets this reaction: “His eyes are saying, get this off me now.” Scott admits: “He hates it because he’s a dog.” Listeners pile in with their own festive dog attire. One text describes a Staffie who becomes an elf and a Labrador who becomes Santa. Another: “Do they enjoy it though? I don’t know.” Scott wonders aloud. His Instagram story hosts the photographic evidence. Tunis cake moment becomes full 80s nostalgia After discussing retro Christmas foods on Elder vs. Millennial, Scott brings in a freshly made Tunis Cake, thanks to his friend Linda. “The first order since 1985.” He describes the decorations lovingly: “Pipe icing and what looks like a fruit bowl — that’s marzipan pears, a marzipan banana, and an orange.” Everyone gathers round to sniff the cake. Pink custard appears. Emilio has never heard of it (“we are old,” Scott says). The easiest quiz dissolves into newborn-related chaos Simon from County Durham plays while caring for one-week-old baby Jim, declared: “Your youngest fan.” During one question, baby Jim makes a long groaning noise, and Simon hesitates disastrously. Scott explains: “Even I know they’re not going to let that go.” The quiz “speaks” to Scott, who announces: “We’d love you to stay on… but we’re out.” Simon gets six and delivers a line that touches listeners and Scott: “You are the friend that you didn’t know you had.” Messages flood in saying that Simon “made me cry.” Shirley Ballas dazzles, opens up, and coaches listeners This morning’s centrepiece is a full, warm, sparkling appearance from Dame Shirley Ballas, who embraces the whole room immediately. Shirley recounts choking on a fishbone In a story both dramatic and funny: “I choked on a fishbone… my feet were dangling!” Her hair stylist Jane had just learned the Heimlich the week before and saved her. Shirley admits she thought she “was a goner.” Strictly instant dance memories The Instant Dance challenge last weekend was, in her words: “Chaos backstage… wigs flying everywhere… Claudia came on in a hat she found in the fancy dress.” She loved it, calling it: “Magnificent… fabulous… I hope they bring it back next year.” She also praises Balvinder, who survived multiple dance-offs: “She is my kind of girl — resilient… great under pressure.” On her new book “Best Foot Forward” Shirley explains she wrote a second autobiography because she didn’t have the courage to discuss certain topics in 2019. She frames each section as a step, like a dance: “Life is full of pivots… and everyone must learn to rise and fall.” She reflects on menopause, breakups, reinvention, marriage, motherhood, and the lessons that continue into her 60s. Her “Shirley’s Shimmers” — advice at the end of each step — include gems like: “If you’re heartbroken… remember they lost you, not the other way around.” Interacting with listener Amy (the Shirley impersonator) Amy performs her Shirley impression live: “I think you are absolutely fantastic, Shirley.” Shirley becomes emotional: “You bring the brightest part to my life during the week.” Coaching Daniel for his workplace Strictly Daniel asks how to stop looking miserable while dancing. Shirley teaches him her technique: “Press your little red button on your shoulder… lights, camera, action.” She tells him to be “flirty,” “musical,” and enjoy his partner Norris. Lloyd Griffith gets even more spotlight Lloyd arrives full of energy and dry humour, immediately admitting: “It’s mad what £6,000 can get for you” — referencing his hair transplant. On return to paradise (the Death in Paradise universe) He explains the expanding “Paraverse”: “Same recipe as Death in Paradise but different ingredients.” He plays Colin, “a little fat cop from Lincolnshire,” his words, not ours. He spent four months filming in Australia — tough life — joking: “It’s awful… the weather’s so nice.” On singing and his choirs Lloyd reveals he is a trained classical singer, having studied music and sung in choirs. He’s doing candlelit Christmas concerts in Grimsby and London, complete with SATB arrangements. Shirley perks up instantly and says she wants to come. On Strictly dreams When Scott suggests Lloyd should do Strictly, Shirley immediately agrees: “We need to get you on the show, sir.” Lloyd jokes that he’s prepped physically: “I’ve had laser hair removal on my shoulders and back.” Scott can’t stop laughing. The big vocal moment Finally, Lloyd sings The Holly and the Ivy live. His voice surprises the whole studio. Shirley delivers the coveted verdict: “It’s a ten from me.” Ellie Brennan is genuinely moved. The post 5 December 2025: Shirley Ballas saves a life and Lloyd Griffith gets a 10 first appeared on Unofficial Mills. View the full article
    • UnofficialStark
      Radio 2 Schedule Changes

      By UnofficialStark · Posted

      I suppose they want the regularity and familiarity of Sara and only want to concede if they have to. That said if Mark's doing two weeks he might as well do a third while he's at it surely...
    • NathanS
      Radio 2 Schedule Changes

      By NathanS · Posted

      Interesting that they've swapped Mark onto drive for that week. Would've made a lot more sense keeping him on breakfast and Sara hosting her own show. I suppose there's some logic there somewhere 🤷
    • UnofficialStark
      Radio 2 Schedule Changes

      By UnofficialStark · Posted

      W/C 5th January 2026: Sara Cox is in for Scott Mills Tina Daheley for Jeremy Vine Mark Goodier for Sara Cox Edith Bowman for Jo Whiley
    • Noah
      Radio 1 Schedule Changes

      By Noah · Posted

      Charlie Tee sits in for Jeremaih Asiamah on Radio1's Soundsystem Party  
    • UnofficialStark
      Radio 2 Schedule Changes

      By UnofficialStark · Posted

      Which all but confirms OJ doing NYD breakfast because Vernon's the only other thing he could've meant by being back on NYD morning.
    • TMD_24
      Radio 1 Schedule Changes

      By TMD_24 · Posted

      Katie and Jerry are doing Going Home W/C 5th January
    • Noah
      Radio 1 Schedule Changes

      By Noah · Posted

      Charley Marlowe sits in for James Cusack on the 3rd & 4th January 2026 Radio1 Dance Malta Highlights 7pm/11pm on 3rd January 2026 Casskidd sits in for Sian Eleri on the 4th January 2026 Lauren Layfield sits in for Dean on the 5th - 8th January 2026 Charlie Tee sits in for Arielle Free on the 8th January 2026
×
×
  • Create New...
I’m raising funds to upgrade the Unofficial Mills servers, improve site speed, and safeguard the full Scott Mills archive. With Scott on breakfast, more people are visiting than ever, so every bit of support helps us grow and keep the archive alive.