Jump to content
Unofficial Mills

DJ Charts - Rate the daytime DJs!


Eternal Helix

Recommended Posts

I know this has been done before but I'm interested: rate the Radio1 daytime DJs in your order of preference. That's Dev, Chris, Fearne, Greg, Scott, Edith, Vernon, Sara, Huw and Reggie. Go go go!

1) Chris Moyles

2) Scott Mills

3) Greg James

4) Sara Cox

5) Huw Stephens

6) Dev

7) Edith Bowman

8 ) Vernon Kay

9) Reggie Yates

10) Fearne Cotton

And Matt Edmondson doesn't count cos he's not a daytime DJ, but if he did he'd be in at number 3ish :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 ) Chris Moyles

2 ) Scott Mills

3 ) Reggie Yates

4 ) Edith Bowman

5 ) Fearne Cotton

6 ) Dev

7 ) Greg James

8 ) Huw Stephens

9 ) Vernon Kay

10 ) Sara Cox

I will add that I can't say I've heard too much of Huw and to an extent Greg and Dev, so that's the reason they may be further down the list than they otherwise might be.

Professional eater of puppy dogs, baby heads and killer of grannies...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Scott Mills - Listened to him since Early breakfast days and he has just got better. His shows are so carefully planned but seem so off the cuff with brilliant features!

2. Chris Moyles - What can I say! He is just the saviour of radio 1! Love the mayhem!

3. Sara Cox - The most entertaining time of my day when sara is on the radio - love it when she covers ANYONE! She suits any time of day!

4. Huw Stephens - Him and Greg should swap as he has a much bigger appeal and perfect personality to hold a show

5. Reggie Yates - Shame he only has set format shows as I think he would be much better on a free show

6. Edith Bowman - Its only once she left weekdays I realised just how good a listen she was

7. Greg James - Promoted to early and needed more time to gain a following - weekends should have been next!

8. Vernon Kay - used to be pretty high but over the last year or 2 iv gone off him

9. Dev - Entertaining enough for earlies and occasional cover but not a regular listen as is quite dull

10. Fearne Cotton - Doesnt deserve the slot she has!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1)Sara Cox- brilliantly entertaining, deserves a far far better show than that she is stuck with.

2) Chris Moyles- irreplacible.

3) Reggie Yates- very listenable, deserved to be promoted over Cotton (their joint shows were always far more entertaining when it was just him than her floundering on her own).

4) Scott Mills- like him but his show can tend to sound fake/contrived.

5) Edith Bowman- has gone way up in my estimations since being replaced by a personality-free robot.

6 ) Vernon Kay- bearable.

7) Greg James- why does he have a national radio show? So bland and devoid of any individuality, really does not deserve to be the so-called future of BBC Radio 1.

8 ) Huw Stephens- well done, you were born in Wales. Any need to mention it every 5 minutes? Wholly underwhelming replacement for Jo Whiley- even feels the need to rip off the Seven Song Shuffle. In essence, complete filler radio- non-essential, put-it-on-if-there's-nothing-better-to-do listening.

9) Fearne Cotton- and well done to you, you're younger than Jo Whiley. Vacuous drivel radio, parachuted in because she's nearer the target audience age. Personifies 'beige'. Typifies the 'age over talent' approach of current BBC Radio 1 thinking.

10) Dev- simply awful. Find a better replacement, someone who doesn't have such ridiculous intonation.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Chris

2. Scott

3. Sara

4. Huw

5. Vernon

6. Fearne

7. Greg (He has got extremely big headed over the last couple of years)

8. Dev

9. Reggie

10. Edith (She is great when covering Grimmy, but awful on weekend breakfast. It's so bloody boring listening to her wang on about films all the time)

Capes :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Scott Mills

2. Huw Stevens

3. Sara Cox

4. Greg James

5. Dev

6. Chris Moyles

7. Fearne Cotton

8. Reggie Yates

9. Edith Bowman

10. Vernon Kay

I really like the first three esp. Scott

I like Greg but he's no where as near as good as we're led to believe

Dev amuses me but it's always a little awkward

Non Comittal about Chris

Fearne is OK, don't mind her but don't willingly listen ditto Reggie

Edith and Vernon dislike

After looking at that I can't believe they let Jo leave :( I'd like to here more Andy George + Jaymo and Adam Catteral as well

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Dev (I live in Australia so he is like my drive time show and I find him funny)

2. Greg James

3. Edith Bowan

4. Chris Moyles

5. Reggie Yates

6. Scott Mills

7. Huw Stephens

8. Vernon Kay

9. Fearne Cotton

10. Sara Cox

What have I got?

Bits and Bobs

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Radio 1 Daytime

1. Scott

2. Chris Moyles's Team

3. Adam Catterall

4. Greg James

5. Matt Edmondson

6. Sara Cox

7. Edith Bowman

8. Hew Stephens

9. Reggie Yates

10. Fearne Cotton

DJs in general

1. MistaJam

2. Scott

3. Simon Hirst

4. Adam Catterall

5. Danny Oakes

6. Nihal

7. Annie Nightingale

8. Kissy Sell Out

9. Annie Mac

10. Richard Bacon

Tweet @DylanDConti

Email [email protected]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Posts

    • Absolutely - life would be dull if we all liked the same things  
    • Dean in for Greg on Tuesday.
    • While it maybe doesn't the power it once has (where being on the A-List was a big deal), It's a big part of the station and I felt probably deserves it's own thread. Have to be honest I haven't been hugely enamored with the playlist in recent times. Radio 1 seem quite heavily wedded to it in weekdays (at least Monday-Thursday) which can lead to the station being repetitive if you listen throughout the day. Even a station like Capital who are known for their limited playlist seem to throw in some older tracks and artists ever so often whereas if it's not Something Songs, 10 Minute Takeover or Anthems you often struggle to hear a song from before 2018. The repetitive nature has been a thing for a while though to be fair - I recall early 2021 in particular it felt like Tiesto's 'The Business' and Olivia Rodrigo's 'Drivers Licence' were played every other hour. Also certain Radio 1 favourites seem almost guaranteed a slot on the playlist even if they don't actually appear to be wildly popular with the target audience to justify it. I get it with your Dua Lipas, Calvin Harrises, Fred Agains  and Olivia Rodrigos as they're all very popular but less so if it's say Cat Burns, Aitch, Royal Blood or Mabel. Which is fine to an extent as Radio 1 has often focussed on promoting new music but then you have great music by other new artists that just never makes it to the playlist as a result.
    • Yep I really struggled with Matt & Jamie which was a shame as otherwise really like Matt. Unfortunately it comes across on-air whether it's actually try or not that Jamie doesn't know a lot about radio and doesn't seem particularly desperate to improve either or if I'm being generous he's playing an act - neither of which particularly appeals. The everyman act can sometimes work but you need to have that natural likability and appeal for it to do so in the way that way Chris Stark did. I mean even towards the end of his stint with Matt Jamie was struggling with getting the Whatsapp number right which is a basic.
    • Have to say even if there is a good reason for Jamie to be off on Thursdays the optics of them a month in still not be able to do a 'normal week' of the scheduled team for a brand new show isn't great. And if Jamie was meant to be away on Thursdays clearly nobody let whoever runs BBC Sounds know. Who would've guessed from the Vick & Jordan days though that it would be Vick who's the everpresent so far (just kidding Vick - really rate her as a DJ and I know she has a lot of other engagements outside of Radio 1).
    • Sorry explain what you mean there please? Danny is unlistenable?? 
    • I dunno if it is me but even Vick and Katie don't sound as good in that slot alone as they did before. Maybe I have just fallen out of love with it all.
    • Agree with most of this above. Listening to only vick and katie today, I was thinking that it doesn't need Jamie. Its very jarring how sometimes he's there and sometimes he isn't. I don't think it needs to be a trio. Surely there are bigger problems at the moment, Danny on a pretty big slot on the station is literally unlistenable.
    • Yes, the length of the time on the station does help as with Annie Mac she did what dance specialist DJs kind of get a bit more favourability with the evening listeners who start out on something specialist. With Annie Mac she did years on dance before going to the flagship new music specialist programme with giving opportunities to new DJs and curating the playlist and having something different from Clara’s more music daytime show where she had to work with the playlist. Had she done more time doing a specialist show later on in the schedule it may have oddly made the moment bigger. Think sometimes what has helped create such a unique sound in presenters and personalities like Annie Mac, Jack and Grimmy for example starting out doing a late show with looser format. Think for the next Jack, Annie and Clara’s of the station do need to have a late live slot and do hope when radio 1 relax is shut down that maybe they change the power down playlist for something with bit more freedom.
    • She is a good broadcaster no doubts but am of the same page with feelings mutual.
    • Clara was always a decent, competent and even good music radio presenter. But equally, she never provoked really strong emotions in me that I must listen or must switch off.
    • Jamie is definitely very divisive though.  Some people's "radio comedy gold" is other people's "unlistenable".  I have liked Matt and Mollie, Matt on his own, Mollie and Jordan etc etc.  But couldn't listen to Matt with Jamie. No hate on Jamie but I just don't like his sense of humour.
    • The dynamics of this are interesting.  Jordan works best with people he knows and he already knows Chris and Sian so from day one it should sound fairly natural.  
    • Have an amazing birthday Scott!  Looking forward to Tuesday! 
×
×
  • Create New...